Skip to content

New England lobster roll

Maine-style cold lobster salad in a toasted split-top bun

From Kittery to Bar Harbor, roadside lobster shacks on the Maine coast serve this every summer: big chunks of sweet lobster meat, barely dressed with mayonnaise, lemon and celery, piled into a hot-dog bun toasted in butter. Over the border in Connecticut they serve it warm with melted butter instead, and both camps think the other is wrong. Chef's tip: dress the lobster lightly, just enough to gloss it; the meat should be the star, not the mayonnaise.
Total time
50 min
Difficulty
medium
Serves
4
One step at a time, big text, timers, read-aloud. Your screen stays on.

Ingredients

Serves4

Shop this recipe on Amazon

Fresh ingredients (4)

Links open Amazon in a new tab. As an Amazon Associate, WhatToEat.Today earns from qualifying purchases.

Method

0/6 done
  1. Step 1: Bring a very large pot of well-salted water to a rolling boil. Check the 2 live lobsters are alive and moving; don't cook any that are dead. Chill them in the freezer for 20 minutes to make them drowsy.

    25 min
  2. Step 2: Plunge the lobsters head first into the boiling water, cover and cook for 9–10 minutes from when the water returns to the boil. They are done when the shells are bright red and an antenna pulls out easily.

    12 min
  3. Step 3: Lift into a bowl of iced water for 5 minutes, then twist off the claws and tails. Crack them, pull out the meat, remove the dark vein from the tail, and cut into 2 cm chunks. Chill.

    20 min
  4. Step 4: Mix the 4 tbsp mayonnaise, 2 tsp lemon juice, 1 celery stick, 1 tbsp chives, ¼ tsp salt and 1 pinch black pepper and fold through the lobster. A common mistake is chopping the meat small and drowning it in dressing, which makes it taste like any seafood salad.

    3 min
  5. Step 5: Spread the flat sides of the 4 split-top hot-dog buns or soft finger rolls with 1 ⅜ oz butter and toast them in a dry frying pan over a medium heat for 1–2 minutes a side, until golden and crisp.

    4 min
  6. Step 6: Line each bun with 4 butter lettuce leaves if using, pile in the lobster and eat straight away, with crisps and a pickle. Keep any leftover lobster in the fridge and eat within a day.

    2 min

Nutrition per serving

Calories
420 kcal
Protein
28 g
Carbs
30 g
Fat
21 g
Fibre
1 g

Nutrition values are estimates.

K
Recipe by

KrazyBadal

All recipes by this chef →

Good to know

How long does new England lobster roll take?
About 50 minutes in total: 30 minutes to prepare and 20 minutes to cook.
How many people does it serve?
4 as written. Change the servings above the ingredients and every amount scales to match.
What can I use instead of lemon juice?
Lime juice, same amount.
What can I use instead of celery stick?
Fennel, same weight.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to cook it.

Rate this recipe

Sign in to rate and review this recipe.

Lemon garlic baked salmon

The easiest way to cook salmon perfectly: a hot oven, a quick lemon-garlic butter and 12 minutes. Serve with new potatoes and greens, or flake it over rice.

by KrazyBadal 0 views

Barbeque sauce

A quick, tangy barbecue sauce of tomato ketchup, onion, butter, vegetarian Worcestershire sauce, vinegar and lemon, sweetened with sugar and warmed with black pepper and chilli flakes. Keep it warm and serve it with barbecued paneer, vegetable skewers, burgers and corn.

by KrazyBadal 0 views

Moist banana bread

The blacker the bananas, the better the loaf. This one is mixed in a single bowl with melted butter and a little brown sugar, so it's soft, deeply banana-y and keeps well for days.

by KrazyBadal 0 views